Disclosure of Material Connection: Some of the links in the post above are "affiliate links." This means if you click on the link and purchase the item, I will receive an affiliate commission. Regardless, I only recommend products or services I use personally and believe will add value to my readers. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission's 16 CFR, Part 255: "Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising."
Are you being kind or do you judge yourself too harshly? Are you competitive and hold high standards (which can be a great thing) — or, are you self-deprecating and judgmental (which isn’t a great thing)?
Judging yourself too harshly can take the power out of self-reflection. Self-reflection is a positive way to explore your standards and your status and make sure they line up. Judging turns constructive criticism into self-abuse.
How can you be sure you are being constructive with your self-critique? Let’s compare these concepts and see where you lie.
Admits flaws while loving the self – Being able to admit flaws allows for growth and change. Realizing you are not where you want to be and refusing to judge yourself for it opens the door for change. Whatever needs to be done to make change is a reality; how you think about it is an emotion. They are not the same. Example: losing weight. Fact: This entails reducing calories and exercising. Lie: You are a bad person who has no self-control, and that’s why you’re overweight.
Is humble – It takes courage to admit you need to change. Our egos get in the way and negative self-talk can help pride in preventing you from overcoming your challenges. Constructive criticism allows for honesty in a safe head-space and doesn’t cast blame or shame.
Wants you to succeed – Constructive criticism is designed for change. The goal is to help you see what’s not working and reach a solution. The hope of constructive criticism is your success.
Is based in shame – Judgement is a painful way of expressing flaws. It causes shame to swallow you and prevents the peace that comes from lovingly accepting what could be better. Shame judges the character of the person, not the action.
Is cruel and fatalistic – Judgement is filled with what could have been instead of what can be. Judgement tells you it’s too late or too hard. Judgement won’t allow forgiveness and repentance. Judgement keeps a tally and demands justice, even when grace is all that is needed.
Thinks you’ve already failed – Judgement sees your current state as the end. That there is no getting back on track, and attempting is feeble and won’t be redemptive.
Your confidence is tied to your emotional health and maturity. How you speak to yourself in your head matters. It is a direct reflection of the confidence you have. If you lean more toward the constructive criticism scale, then yay for you! If you find yourself leaning toward judgement, stop judging and get yourself some help. You can change how you think and improve your inner dialogue.